All bookseller links are provided so you can get more information about a book. We have affiliate relationships with Barefoot Books, Amazon.com, and Tapestry Books. All revenue generated from sales through these venues is used strictly to cover website costs and minimize donation requests and fundraising campaigns.
What teacher has the bigger influence? The one who spends 900 hours in school with them or the one at home who spends ... More
Summary: Seven years ago, Xing (pronounced "shing") and his parents emigrated from China, arriving in the United States. When Xing was a young boy in China, he was often asked to sing. Because of his beautiful voice, his father wanted Xing to have the chance to develop his gift in America. Xing, who wants to be called "Kris" to get people to stop butchering his name, has been cast as the lead in his school's production of The Man of Jerusalem. But his father would never hear his voice again. One day several years ago, when Kris and his dad were walking home from the train station, a pickup truck driving too fast killed his father, then sped away. No one paid for the crime - except Xing and his mother. Kris wanted nothing more than to return to China; his mother said they were staying in America and quietly blaming him for what happened. This is a young adult novel that through the darkness, is part mystery, part coming of age.
Type of Reading: anytime reading, independent reading, read aloud book
Recommended Age: read together: 12 and up; read yourself: 14 and up
Young Reader Reaction: Although I admired the books structure and liked how the author wove the disparate story lines together, the plot itself did not catch my interest. It was vague and somewhat unclear. It was resolved far too quickly after not being given enough attention for a long stretch of the novel. Xing himself comes off as a regular high-school student,
and while his unique situation makes for interesting and believable teenage angst, his reactions to developing events are often over-the-top and/or heavy-handed. This is entirely understandable, but the focus of the story is shifted from a teenager dealing with
racism and prejudice to a teenager focusing only on the negative things in his life and raging about them. The result is that Xing is not an entirely-likeable protagonist. I enjoyed the book, but several flaws kept me from becoming a true fan. Crossing is rated as a young adult novel, but there are some graphic scenes that would push readership to the higher end of the teen spectrum (16 to 17). Mystery fans should also take a look at it, though the resolution of the mystery is not entirely clear and may disappoint those looking for complete closure.
Adult Reader Reaction: Crossing is a dark story and my feelings about Xing/Kris are hard to pin down. Looking at the world through Xing's eyes is not only informative but is down-right frightening When I finished reading, I immediately went back to the front and started skimming for clues. Like all good mysteries, the ending is a surprise. Crossing would be an incredible read-aloud in a classroom session.
Pros: Suspense will keep readers turning the pages and wanting to know who is killing all of these high school students.
Cons: Crossing makes continual reference to Seung-Hui Cho, the Virginia Tech student who killed 32 people in April 2007. Sometimes the reference came from Xing, sometimes from his ignorant schoolmates who equated Chinese and South Korean as "the same thing." the references will also keep some people from reading it, and I hate when that happens to a really great story.
Borrow or Buy: Borrow, at least. This is not a book for every reader. There are serious issues and death, which may bother some readers (or their parents).
Educational Themes: There are a number of themes that will resonate with teens. Some are more personal (like fitting in) and others much broader (like cultural acceptance).
Notes: The publicist representing the author donated a copy of this book to the Reading Tub® for review consideration because we provide an independent, unbiased profiles. This book will be given to a nonprofit to help readers in need.
Literary Categories: Fiction - young adult, realistic fiction, coming of age, mystery, death
Date(s) Reviewed: May 2010, July 2011
Other Reviews: No Critics Reviews found at the time of this review. See reader feedback at barnesandnoble.com and amazon.com.