All bookseller links are provided so you can get more information about a book. We have affiliate relationships with Barefoot Books, Amazon.com, and Tapestry Books. All revenue generated from sales through these venues is used strictly to cover website costs and minimize donation requests and fundraising campaigns.
“There is more treasure in books than in all the pirate's loot on Treasure Island.”
Summary: Unlike many of the Sister series titles, this one puts just a couple of the girls at center stage. Lu received a gift of riding lessons for her birthday, but she hates horses. Donna loves horses but cannot afford lessons. Sounds like a match made in heaven. Or so the girls think when they switch identities. Their plan backfires when Lu (as Donna) appears in the paper as an award-winning rider. Now what? This is a chapter book series for reluctant readers (reading at ages 7-8).
Type of Reading: family reading, read aloud book, remedial reader
Recommended Age: read together: 7 to 10; read yourself: 9 to 12
Interest Level: 7 to 12
Age of Child: Read by a 12-year-old girl.
Young Reader Reaction: Given how old these girls look, this didn’t seem too realistic that they would be gaga for horses. I did kind of like the story, but it wasn’t too believable; especially when Lu isn’t too upset when she has to muck out stalls! UGH!
Adult Reader Reaction: I also had trouble with how realistic this story would be or how girls could relate (how many girls get riding lessons for their birthday?)
Pros: Having two main characters as the focus made this less “busy” and easier to follow than some of the other titles in this series.
Cons: The poor posture of the characters as shown in the illustrations bothers me. Anyone taking riding lessons would be forced to abandon that “round shouldered look”.
Borrow or Buy: This is for a niche audience. I don’t think I would borrow or buy this book unless I had a horse-crazy girl to give it to (limited audience).
Educational Themes: The message in this book is about the importance of telling the truth. Problem solving could be taught by presenting the problem to students, asking them to come up with alternatives to Donna's and Lu’s solution.
Literary Categories: Fiction - friendship, reluctant reader, remedial reading, series book
Date(s) Reviewed: December 2007
Other Reviews: No Critics' Reviews or reader feedback found at bn.com (Barnes & Noble) or borders.com. We’re interested in your review. Please enter your Name (and blog in Parenthesis), then copy/paste your post link in the URL field. With a link exchange, we both benefit because interested readers can visit you too!